The d'Alembert paradox, annunciated in 1752, was established after it was shown that the result of a net zero drag, obtained by applying potential theory to the incompressible flow past a sphere, was in contradiction with experimental results which showed a positive drag. Interpreting the result as a flaw in the theory, resulted in the declaration of the paradox. Following d'Alembert, we assume a potential motion, and proceed to analyze the consequences of this assumption using the global principles of continuum mechanics. We show that if the fluid is inviscid, the potential motion is thermodynamically admissible, the drag is zero, and the motion can persist indefinitely. Although no conventional fluid is available to either falsify (or validate), this result experimentally, in principle, the theory could be tested by using a superfluid, such as liquid Helium. If the fluid is viscous, we show that the potential irrotational motion is thermodynamically inadmissible, it is in violation of the second law of thermodynamics, and hence such a motion cannot persist. Indeed, observations show that when a rigid body is impulsively set into motion, an irrotational motion may exist initially but does not persist. Any flow property which is derived from a thermodynamically inadmissible motion cannot be expected to be in agreement with experimental data. As an illustration we show that the drag, calculated from the viscous potential solution of the flow past a sphere, is zero. We submit that since the theory of continuum mechanics predicts that no agreement between results obtained from viscous potential theory and experimental data can be expected, there is no room for a paradox once a contradiction is in fact observed. In nature, or under experimental conditions, the nonpersistence of the thermodynamically inadmissible motion proceeds in a breakup of the irrotational motion which transforms into a rotational and obviously admissible motion. We show that by selecting boundary conditions, required in the solution of the differential equations of motion, such that they satisfy the Clausius–Duhem jump conditions inequality, the thermodynamic admissibility of the solution is a priori assured. We also show the vorticity distribution at the wall associated with the particular choice of boundary condition.
Skip Nav Destination
Article navigation
July 2015
Research-Article
The Resolution of d'Alembert's Paradox and Thermodynamic Admissibility
Gerald G. Kleinstein
Gerald G. Kleinstein
Adjunct Professor
Department of Mechanical
and Industrial Engineering,
Department of Mechanical
and Industrial Engineering,
Northeastern University
,Boston, MA 02215
Search for other works by this author on:
Gerald G. Kleinstein
Adjunct Professor
Department of Mechanical
and Industrial Engineering,
Department of Mechanical
and Industrial Engineering,
Northeastern University
,Boston, MA 02215
Contributed by the Advanced Energy Systems Division of ASME for publication in the JOURNAL OF ENERGY RESOURCES TECHNOLOGY. Manuscript received November 4, 2014; final manuscript received November 10, 2014; published online March 9, 2015. Editor: Hameed Metghalchi.
J. Energy Resour. Technol. Jul 2015, 137(4): 042001 (7 pages)
Published Online: July 1, 2015
Article history
Received:
November 4, 2014
Revision Received:
November 10, 2014
Online:
March 9, 2015
Citation
Kleinstein, G. G. (July 1, 2015). "The Resolution of d'Alembert's Paradox and Thermodynamic Admissibility." ASME. J. Energy Resour. Technol. July 2015; 137(4): 042001. https://doi.org/10.1115/1.4029105
Download citation file:
Get Email Alerts
Cited By
Assessing Hydrogen–Ammonia Ratios to Achieve Rapid Kernel Inception in Spark-Ignition Engines
J. Energy Resour. Technol (June 2024)
Characterization of Surfactant Adsorption Profile in Carbonates Under Severe Reservoir Conditions With Geochemical Modeling Approach
J. Energy Resour. Technol (June 2024)
Techno-Economic and Environmental Analysis of a Hybrid Power System Formed From Solid Oxide Fuel Cell, Gas Turbine, and Organic Rankine Cycle
J. Energy Resour. Technol (July 2024)
Artificial Intelligence for Thermal Energy Storage Enhancement: A Comprehensive Review
J. Energy Resour. Technol (June 2024)
Related Articles
The Eshelby Tensors in a Finite Spherical Domain—Part II: Applications to Homogenization
J. Appl. Mech (July,2007)
High-Order Eulerian Simulations of Multimaterial Elastic–Plastic Flow
J. Fluids Eng (May,2018)
Level-Set Computations of Free Surface Rotational Flows
J. Fluids Eng (November,2005)
A Growth Mixture Theory for Cartilage With Application to Growth-Related Experiments on Cartilage Explants
J Biomech Eng (April,2003)
Related Proceedings Papers
Related Chapters
VISVE, a Vorticity Based Model Applied to Cavitating Flow around a 2-D Hydrofoil
Proceedings of the 10th International Symposium on Cavitation (CAV2018)
The Design and Implement of Remote Inclinometer for Power Towers Based on MXA2500G/GSM
International Conference on Mechanical and Electrical Technology, 3rd, (ICMET-China 2011), Volumes 1–3
Experimental Investigation of Ventilated Supercavitation Under Unsteady Conditions
Proceedings of the 10th International Symposium on Cavitation (CAV2018)